Imposing a Tariff on China… Good Idea?

Tom Landquist Political Digest 5 Comments

President-elect Trump has discussed extensively his desire to see China labeled as a currency manipulator, and has repeatedly called for a tariff on “all” Chinese goods. Whether or not that was campaign bluster, or a policy stance his administration will pursue, this is an issue that deserves a look.

What is a Tariff?

A tariff is simply a tax on imported goods. This tax can be levied for a host of reasons and isn’t necessarily done on a countrywide scale. It is often for individual items, or industries.

Why Do They Exist?

Simply put, they help the government maintain control of trade policies and help regulate pricing and wages within industries.

For example, if I was importing a widget at a cost for $1 and the US wanted domestic manufacturers who have a cost of $1.10 to produce the same widget for our markets and be competitive, they would impose a 10% tariff of the widget, and the consumers end cost would be the same for buying either widget. This protects the US manufacturer, produces tax revenue for the government, and has leveled the pricing for the consumer.

Why Not Use Them?

The process above is a very closed off example that doesn’t take the real world into account. Keep that in mind.

If we decided to say impose a large tariff on Chinese goods, the cost of real goods would increase here in the US. Yuck.

We have become dependent on imported goods, and not just completed items, but the components used inside of larger products which are assembled in the US. A 35% increase in costs associated with the largest supplier of our imported goods would lead to a vast increase in costs for our everyday items.

When discussing China, in particular, it’s important to realize that our actions have consequences we can’t necessarily control.

Apple has been a company in the spotlight of this battle, and recently the Chinese government has made it clear that any actions against them would hurt Apple’s access to their markets, as well as other companies, industries and individuals which do business with China.

Is It Really that Big of a Deal?

To answer this question we have to step back and look at this from a larger scale, and that scale considers the very makeup of the earth and its resources.

Rare Earth Elements…. The Big Example

Rare earth elements/metals are absolutely critical to the future of this planet with our current technological paths. They go in everything from cell phones and televisions, to invaluable defensive needs like radar, night vision, guided weapons, stealth technology, and our fiber optic technology applications. They are essentially the lifeblood of the entire modern world we have taken for granted.

The current estimates of total rare earth elements puts the number around 130 million metric tons. China has access to 55 million tons themselves, and the US has relatively small reserves in comparison at 1.8 million tons.

In 2015, China produced 105,000 metric tons from their mines compared to 4,100 metric tons by the US. This level of supply and production mixed with an ever growing demand has China positioned to control the current market of rare earth elements, and by default, all the products and services that use those materials, both civilian and government.

In other words…

This is a much more complicated issue with consequences that reach far beyond manufacturing jobs in the rust belt. The answers to our problems may not be as simple as we had originally hoped.

The international economy isn’t going away, particularly where raw materials are concerned, and in a global market, global pricing will drive down both wages and cost of goods in countries with higher median incomes.

We don’t have the answers to this issue, but we all share the concerns and a large portion of us have shared the burden of this transitionary period in our history. How our workforce adapts to a global economy, changes in technology, robotics, automation and the rest of the changes just around the horizon remains to be seen.

One thing is for certain, we must quickly come together around issues we can identify, and work towards solutions before we get left behind.

Please make sure you share this with your friends on your social media pages!

Comments 5

  1. I think the tariff talk is a good start to try to get something done. I am 55, and have seen my country go from “made in America” to “Made in China” or “Hecho in Mexico”, in just 30 short years. Our stores are flooded with foreign products and nearly everything I own is foreign. I can see lost American jobs as I stop and look at my “prosperity”.

    Is Trump right on how the Chinese have manipulated their currency?

    Not sure, but I just saw an interview at a Carrier plant in Mexico. The Mexicans work package is 6 bucks an hour, and the American package is 37 bucks an hour, according to the reporter.

    This is a huge lure for companies to leave the U.S.

    If this goes on unfettered, I forecast little to no jobs in manufacturing sectors in 50 years.

    This message from Trump may not be the answer, but it is possibly the alarm bell we need to see of an approaching storm.

    As we lose manufacturing, we lose our greatness.

    The greatest manufacturer of the world(U.S.) transformed their industrial machine to the war machine in WWII. (This saved civilization from the Axis powers).

    Time will tell if things can be reversed, but I am glad that at least there is dialogue about this threat.

    1. This issue is a complicated one that likely doesn’t have a singular answer. The global economy is upon us whether we like it or not, and we need a plan to stay relevant in key industries as things advance.

  2. True, it(global economy) is here to stay.

    BTW….we paid 1,200 dollars for a Chinese made couch that lasted less than a year.

    Sometimes you DONT get what you paid for…..LOL

  3. Thanks for the marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you’re a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will eventually come back from now on. I want to encourage you to ultimately
    continue your great job, have a nice day!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *